Naturepedic Vs Saatva
When choosing between Naturepedic and Saatva, you'll find two distinct approaches to premium mattresses. Naturepedic emphasizes organic materials with GOTS-certified cotton and GOLS-certified latex, plus customizable comfort layers you can adjust. Saatva offers luxury hybrid designs at lower price points ($925-$5050) with pre-configured comfort levels and zoned lumbar support. While Naturepedic's chemical-free construction comes at a higher cost, Saatva provides longer trial periods (365 nights vs. 100) and a lifetime warranty. Both excel at temperature regulation and durability, but your choice depends on whether organic certification or value pricing matters more to your sleep investment.
Key Construction Differences
Both Naturepedic and Saatva take distinct approaches to mattress construction, with their primary differences lying in material certifications and assembly methods.
While Naturepedic emphasizes GOTS-certified organic cotton and GOLS-certified latex, Saatva utilizes high-quality but not fully certified organic materials.
You'll find that Naturepedic's construction requires hands-on assembly, featuring customizable inserts that let you adjust the mattress's firmness.
The layers include organic cotton batting, micro-coils, and encased coils, topped with a quilted cover combining wool and PLA material.
In contrast, Saatva delivers a ready-to-use mattress with a pre-assembled Euro pillow top and dual coil system.
The internal structure of these mattresses also differs considerably. The Naturepedic includes 3-inch glueless micro-coils for enhanced comfort and support.
Saatva incorporates CertiPUR-US certified memory foam with a double layer of recycled steel coils (14.5 and 13-gauge), focusing on spinal alignment.
Naturepedic, however, uses natural materials exclusively, combining organic components with plant-based PLA from non-GMO sugarcane.
This construction creates a chemical-free sleep environment while maintaining durability through its innovative use of sustainable materials.
Comfort and Support Levels
Comparing comfort and support levels reveals distinct differences between Naturepedic and Saatva's flagship models.
The Naturepedic EOS shows a notable 2.71-inch sinkage depth during testing, providing balanced body contouring. The mattress offers superior customization with its interchangeable comfort layers, allowing you to adjust firmness by swapping the 3-inch latex layers. You'll find pressure relief through 6 inches of organic latex, while an 8-inch pocketed coil system provides targeted support.
The Saatva Classic takes a different approach with its pre-configured comfort levels. You'll get a 3-inch Euro pillow top and memory foam layer, but you can't modify the mattress after purchase. The dual-coil system, featuring 14.5-gauge and 13-gauge steel coils, delivers reliable support for most sleepers.
Both mattresses excel in specific areas:
Naturepedic EOS:
- Customizable firmness options
- Split comfort configurations available
- Superior edge support
- Natural temperature regulation
Saatva Classic:
- Three distinct firmness levels
- Zoned lumbar support
- Good pressure relief for side sleepers
- Enhanced breathability through minimal foam use
For those seeking adjustability, you'll prefer Naturepedic's design. If you're confident in your firmness preference, Saatva's preset options offer excellent value.
Temperature Regulation
Temperature regulation ties directly into overall comfort, and these two mattresses take distinct approaches to keeping you cool at night.
Naturepedic utilizes organic cotton, wool batting, and latex layers to create a naturally cooling sleep surface that wicks away moisture effectively.
The Saatva Classic demonstrates impressive temperature control through documented testing, reaching a maximum temperature of 88.6°F – about 1.1°F cooler than average.
The 100-night trial period ensures you can thoroughly evaluate the cooling performance over different seasons.
You'll experience rapid heat dissipation, with nearly 9°F decline within five minutes of contact.
Both mattresses excel in different ways:
Naturepedic:
- Natural moisture-wicking through organic materials
- Consistent cooling across all sleeping positions
- Enhanced breathability without chemical additives
Saatva:
- Measurable cooling performance with specific temperature data
- High-response poly foams for quick heat dispersal
- Strong edge support that maintains cooling properties
While both mattresses perform well in temperature regulation, you'll find Naturepedic's approach more suitable if you prefer organic materials.
The Saatva offers more traditionally engineered cooling with documented performance metrics.
Neither mattress uses memory foam, helping them avoid the heat retention issues common in foam-based designs.
Price Comparison
Your wallet will feel a noticeable difference between these two mattress brands, with Naturepedic commanding higher prices due to its organic materials and specialized craftsmanship.
While Saatva's entry-level models start at $925, Naturepedic's begin at $1,199 for most adult mattresses.
The price gap becomes more apparent when comparing specific models. Saatva's Classic queen mattress tops out at $2,095 before discounts, while Naturepedic's Concerto Organic Pillow Top reaches $2,799 for the same size.
You'll find even steeper prices with Naturepedic's premium offerings, like the EOS Pillowtop at $3,099. Saatva maintains high value with their CertiPUR-US® certified mattresses.
Both brands offer regular discounts to soften the blow. You can expect 12-15% off Saatva's MSRP during sales events, while Naturepedic provides similar promotional opportunities.
When it comes to additional costs, Saatva includes free white glove delivery and old mattress removal but charges a $99 return fee. Naturepedic offers free shipping and returns but doesn't include white glove service.
The higher price point of Naturepedic reflects its organic certifications and Amish craftsmanship.
Trial Period and Warranties
Beyond the price tags, both companies offer strong customer assurance programs, though with notable differences.
Saatva provides a more generous trial period of 365 nights, while Naturepedic offers 100 nights for mattress testing. You'll need to keep your Naturepedic mattress for at least 30 days before returning it, though Saatva doesn't require a break-in period.
When it comes to warranties, Naturepedic extends better coverage with a 25-year limited warranty on their main mattress lines, compared to Saatva's 15-year warranty. As a U.S.-based certified organic manufacturer, Naturepedic brings 20 years of experience to their warranty service. If you're considering a baby crib mattress, Naturepedic's lifetime warranty is particularly impressive.
Both companies include free shipping, but Saatva charges a $99 transportation fee for returns.
Naturepedic offers additional flexibility with their 100-day EOS layer swap program, letting you adjust comfort levels without returning the entire mattress.
For accessories, you'll get a 30-day money-back guarantee and 1-year warranty from Naturepedic.
Both companies maintain strong warranty support systems, though specific terms may vary if you purchase through third-party retailers.
Customer Reviews
When comparing real customer experiences, both Naturepedic and Saatva receive impressive feedback, with Saatva scoring slightly higher at 9.5/10 compared to Naturepedic's 9.3/10.
Naturepedic customers consistently report high satisfaction levels, with an average rating of 4.7 out of five stars across over 20 reviews. You'll find frequent mentions of improved sleep quality and reduced pain, particularly from users with specific health conditions. The mattress's hand-built construction contributes significantly to its durability and performance. The mattress's cooling properties and motion isolation features receive significant praise from couples and those prone to overheating.
Saatva distinguishes itself through exceptional back pain relief and thorough customer support resources. While both brands excel in edge support, Saatva's more competitive pricing range ($925-$5050) makes it accessible to a broader market compared to Naturepedic ($1199-$9999).
Both manufacturers earn recognition for their quality construction, though they approach it differently. Naturepedic emphasizes organic materials and chemical-free manufacturing, garnering loyalty from health-conscious consumers.
The availability of four firmness levels guarantees you'll find your ideal comfort level, with the cushion-firm option emerging as a popular choice among users seeking balanced support.
Making Your Final Choice
After examining customer experiences and detailed specifications, selecting between Naturepedic and Saatva comes down to prioritizing what matters most to you.
If you're committed to organic materials and chemical-free sleep, Naturepedic's GOTS-certified cotton and GOLS-certified latex make it a compelling choice, despite its higher price point starting at $1,199.
Saatva offers exceptional value with prices starting at $925, plus you'll get a more generous trial period (365 nights versus Naturepedic's 100 nights) and lifetime warranty. At 110 pounds, the Saatva queen mattress is easier to maneuver during setup compared to many competitors.
Their individually wrapped coils and luxury firm options provide excellent support for most sleep styles.
Consider these key decision factors:
- Budget: Saatva typically costs less while offering premium features
- Materials: Naturepedic excels in organic certifications
- Warranty: Saatva's lifetime coverage versus Naturepedic's 25-year warranty
- Durability: Saatva shows consistent longevity, while Naturepedic has some variability
- Firmness: Both offer multiple options, with Saatva providing more variety
- Trial Period: Saatva's year-long trial offers more time to decide
Your choice should align with your priorities regarding organic materials, budget constraints, and preferred sleep experience.
